Throughout an look on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon in January 2015, Nicole Kidman dropped a bomb on the late-night host: he might have dated her! Whereas recounting the story of how they first met again within the early 2000s — a mutual good friend named Rick supplied to introduce the 2 by bringing Nicole to Jimmy’s NYC residence — the Oscar winner could not include herself as she revealed that she “favored” the then-SNL star and had thought of the go to “a hangout.”

Unbeknownst to Jimmy, he completely blew his probabilities at touchdown the Australian magnificence; between his providing of brie cheese and corn chips, lack of communication, and the truth that he “put on a online game,” Nicole admitted, “After about an hour and a half, I believed, ‘He had no curiosity, that is so embarrassing.'” Evidently, Jimmy was horrified, and the next week, he tweeted, “I’m so embarrassed.” Watch all the video above to relive the hilarious dialog.